Top 5 Best Under Counter Ice Makers For 2024: (Ranked and Reviewed)

In the world of home appliances, finding the perfect undercounter ice maker can be a chilling challenge. That’s why we’ve taken it upon ourselves to do the hard work for you. From ice production capacity to ease of installation and maintenance, we left no icicle unturned in our quest to uncover the top contenders.

It’s important to note that, like any appliance, each ice maker comes with its own pros and cons, but that’s precisely why we’re here—to guide you toward the ideal investment for your ice-cold desires.

How Did We Choose The Best Undercounter Ice Makers?

Since an under-counter Ice maker can easily be incorporated into a cabinet, give as much thought as possible into selecting a device.

In selecting the ideal under counter ice maker, we evaluated several essential features: Our team evaluated 5 ice-maker products and narrowed them down based on their performance, durability, ease-in-use and prices.

This study examined production rates, storage capacities, and factors contributing to ice quality, such as filtering and patented technologies. We have selected ice makers that have durable materials.

What Criteria Did We Use When Ranking The Best UnderCounter Ice Maker?

1. Ice Production Capacity: The ice maker should also feature two key characteristics: ice production and ice capacity. Ice capacity tells us how much ice the device can hold at one moment. It usually varies from 25 pounds on built-in models to just over 3 pounds for a countertop ice maker.

2. Ice Cube Quality: Ice cube quality matters for both aesthetics and functionality. Uniform and Clear ice cubes look more appealing in drinks and melt more slowly, keeping your beverages cold without diluting them too quickly. Whether it’s Nugget Ice or Crescent Shaped Ice Cubes, High-quality ice cubes enhance the drinking experience, making it a critical factor for those who appreciate the finer details. An Easy-to-Clean Stainless Steel Ice Storage Bin Can Help Maintain Clear Ice Technology.

3. Installation and Maintenance: Unlike a Countertop Ice Maker, the Ease of installation and maintenance can significantly impact your satisfaction with the ice maker. A straightforward installation process means you can start using your ice maker quickly without needing professional assistance. Similarly, easy maintenance ensures that cleaning and upkeep are not time-consuming or complicated tasks, extending the lifespan of your appliance.

4. Energy Efficiency: Energy Star efficiency is crucial for several reasons. First, it helps reduce your environmental footprint, making your home more eco-friendly. Second, an energy-efficient ice maker can lower electricity bills over time, saving you money. Given the increasing focus on sustainability and cost savings, energy efficiency is an increasingly important consideration for many consumers.

5. Price and Value: Price and value are always relevant when purchasing. While you want an ice maker that meets your needs and preferences, staying within your budget is also essential. The best undercounter ice maker offers a balance between performance and affordability. Assessing the long-term value, including the expected lifespan and included features, helps ensure you make a wise investment.

What to Consider When Choosing an Undercounter Ice Maker

Choosing the right undercounter ice maker that’s best for your situation can be a tricky one.

Here’s a list of key aspects to consider:

1. Size and Capacity: Measure the space where you plan to install the ice maker. Ensure the unit’s dimensions fit under your counter. Also, consider the ice production capacity (how much ice it makes daily) and storage capacity (how much it can hold at once).
2. Type of Ice: Different ice makers produce different types of ice, like cubes, nuggets, or flakes. Consider what kind of ice best suits your needs, whether displaysfor beverages, food display, or medical use.
3. Energy Efficiency: Look for energy-efficient models to save on electricity bills and reduce environmental impact. Energy Star-certified models are often a good choice.
4. Ease of Installation: Check if the ice maker requires a dedicated water line and drain. Some models have more complex installation requirements than others.
5. Maintenance and Cleaning: Regular cleaning is essential for hygiene. Consider models with easy-to-clean features and those that may have self-cleaning cycles.
6. Noise Level: Some ice makers can be noisy. If the noise level is a concern, look for models advertised as quiet or check user reviews for feedback on noise levels.
7. Cost: Prices vary widely based on size, capacity, brand, and features. Set a budget and consider long-term costs like energy consumption and maintenance.
8. Brand Reputation and Warranty: Choose a reputable brand. Check the warranty details, as an extended warranty can offer peace of mind and potentially save on future repair costs.
9. Additional Features: Some models offer extra features like a water filter, ice size selection, or a reversible door to fit the direction of your kitchen layout.
10. User Reviews and Recommendations: Look for reviews and recommendations online to see how users feel about the performance and reliability of the ice maker.

One Last Thing Before We Dive into the Ice Bin

The ice production capacity is fundamental when selecting the best undercounter ice maker, as it determines the appliance’s ability to meet your daily ice needs.

To ensure you get the best undercounter ice maker for your home, prioritize ice cube quality, as clear and uniform ice cubes enhance the overall experience.

Ease of installation and maintenance is crucial for the best undercounter ice maker because it ensures a hassle-free setup and ongoing upkeep.

Furthermore, choosing the best undercounter ice maker benefits the environment and reduces electricity bills.

While searching for the best undercounter ice maker, keep an eye on the price and value proposition to find an appliance that balances performance and affordability.

What Are The Best UnderCounter Ice Makers?

Get Ready to find the perfect Undercounter ice maker that best serves you on your ice-making journey. This list of the top 5 will let you choose an undercounter ice maker that fits your space, meets your needs, and provides reliable service.

---

(BEST OVERALL)
EUHOMY Commercial Under Counter Ice Maker

Ice Shape: Cube, Chewable Nugget Ice

Production Speed: 80 Lbs/Day -20 Minutes per Batch

Ice Storage Capacity: 24 Pounds of ice

Dimensions: 18.47″D x 14.96″W x 33.9″H

Energy Star certified & Clear ice technology

Pros:

1. High Ice Production Capacity: The EUHOMY Commercial Ice Maker boasts an impressive 80 lbs/day ice production capacity, making it suitable for commercial and home use.

2. Auto-Cleaning Function: This Ice Maker Includes an auto-cleaning function that simplifies maintenance, ensuring that the ice maker remains clean and hygienic with minimal effort from the user.

3. Convenient Drain Pump: The built-in drain pump on this ice maker enhances flexibility in installation, allowing the unit to be placed in various locations without the need for a gravity drain, which can be especially useful in commercial settings.

4. 24-Hour Timer: The 24-hour timer feature on this ice maker enables users to program ice production according to their specific needs, helping to conserve energy during off-peak hours.

5. Stainless Steel Build: The stainless steel construction provides durability and adds a sleek and modern aesthetic, suitable for both commercial and residential kitchens.

Cons:

1. Large Footprint: Given its high ice production capacity, the EUHOMY Commercial ice maker may have a larger physical footprint, requiring adequate space for installation.

2. Price: This commercial-grade ice maker may be on the higher end of the price spectrum, which could be a potential drawback for budget-conscious consumers.

3. Noise Level: This High-capacity ice maker can sometimes generate noticeable noise during operation compared to other ice makers. While specific noise levels may vary, users may want to consider noise as a factor, especially in residential settings.

4. 24 lbs Storage Capacity: While the daily production capacity is high, the storage capacity of 24 lbs may be considered relatively small for an ice maker in some commercial settings where a constant supply of ice is required.

5. Maintenance Requirements: While the auto-cleaning function is a pro, it’s essential to follow maintenance instructions to ensure proper operation for this ice maker. Users should be prepared for occasional cleaning tasks to keep the machine running efficiently.

The EUHOMY Commercial UnderCounter Ice Machine is our best choice overall for our best undercounter ice machines due to its winning combination of high ice production capacity, ease of maintenance, and versatile features.

With an impressive 80 lbs/day ice production capacity, it caters to residential and commercial demands.

The auto-cleaning function simplifies maintenance, ensuring long-term reliability and hygiene. Its built-in drain pump offers installation flexibility, and the 24-hour timer allows users to produce ice to their schedules while conserving energy. With a sleek stainless steel design, it performs excellently and adds a touch of elegance to any setting.

While it may come at a slightly higher price point, its well-rounded performance, durability, and user-friendly features make it the best choice for those seeking a top-tier under counter ice maker.

(BEST VALUE)
COSTWAY Commercial Ice Machine

Ice Shape: Cube, chewable nugget ice

Production Speed: 88 Lbs/Day -18 Minutes Per Batch

Ice Storage Capacity: 8.8 lbs of ice

Dimensions: 13.5 x 13 x 23.5 inches

Energy star certified

Pros:

1. High Ice Production Capacity: The COSTWAY Automatic Portable Ice Maker boasts an impressive 88 lbs/day ice production capacity, making it suitable for various commercial settings.

2. Customizable Ice Thickness: The ability to control ice thickness on this ice maker allows users to tailor ice cubes to their specific requirements, enhancing the versatility of restaurant quality ice.

3. Viewing Window: The costway commercial ice machine window allows users to conveniently observe the ice-making process and check the ice cube shape without opening the machine, reducing interruptions.

4. Auto-Clean Function: The auto-clean feature simplifies the cleaning process, ensuring the machine remains sanitary and hygienic with ease.

5. Interior Lighting: Interior lighting enhances visibility inside the ice maker, making it easier to monitor the ice-making process and maintain cleanliness.

6. Durable Construction: The steel internal construction, enclosure, and stainless steel surface panel contribute to the machine’s durability and longevity.

7. Thermal Insulation: Thick thermal insulation helps maintain ice quality and energy efficiency.

8. Undercounter ice machine with Ice Scoop

Cons:

1. Large Size: The unit’s high ice production capacity may result in a larger physical footprint, requiring ample space for installation in crowded settings.

2. Complex Controls: Some users may find the controls for adjusting ice thickness and other settings slightly complex, requiring a learning curve.

3. Noise Level: Like many high-capacity ice makers, this unit may generate noticeable noise during operation, which could be considered in quieter environments.

4. Price: While it offers robust features, the COSTWAY Commercial Ice Maker may be on the higher end of the price range, which could affect budget-conscious buyers.

5. Maintenance Requirements: While it has an auto-clean function, users should still be prepared for routine maintenance tasks to ensure optimal performance and cleanliness.

6. Small Storage Capacity to store ice

Overall, the COSTWAY Commercial Ice Machine presents a powerful ice production capacity and several user-friendly features, making it suitable for various Commercial tight Spaces like coffee Shops or Bars.

However, prospective buyers should assess the unit’s size, complexity, and noise level against their needs and budget considerations.

(MOST FEATURES)
Joy Pebble Commercial Ice Maker

Ice Shape: Cube, chewable nugget ice

Production Speed: 100 Lbs/Day -20 Minutes per Batch- 6,000+ Cubes/ 24hrs

Ice Storage Capacity: 33 Pounds of ice

Dimensions: 15.28″D x 14.57″W x 31.42″H

Energy star certified

Pros:

1. High Ice Production Capacity: The 100 lbs/day ice production capacity makes fresh ice quickly therefore highly suitable high-demand environments such as bars, restaurants, and offices.

2. Large Ice Storage Basket: With a 33 lbs ice storage basket, this machine can store a significant large quantities of ice, reducing the need for constant monitoring and refilling and cutting back on ice making time.

3. 2-Way Water Adding: The 2-way water adding feature provides flexibility in water source options, making installation more convenient.

4. Customizable Ice Thickness: The 7-gear ice thickness control allows users to tailor ice type to their preferences, enhancing versatility.

5. 24-Hour Timer: The 24-hour timer feature enables users to program ice production according to their schedules, helping conserve energy during off-peak hours.

6. Self-Cleaning Function: The self-cleaning ice maker simplifies maintenance and ensures a hygienic ice production process.

7. Easy Hook up: Attachments for Bottled Water or Tap Water with Water Quality Sensor

Cons:

1. Large Size: This commercial ice machine may have a larger physical footprint, requiring ample space for installation in crowded settings or smaller kitchens.

2. Noise Level: Commercial-grade ice makers can generate noticeable noise during operation, which could be considered in quieter environments like offices or homes.

3. Price: While it offers impressive features, this machine’s price may be higher, which could impact budget-conscious buyers.

4. Complexity: Some users may find the controls and settings, including the ice thickness control, somewhat complex, requiring a learning curve.

5. Maintenance Requirements: Despite the self-cleaning function, regular maintenance is essential to ensure optimal performance and cleanliness over time.

The Joy Pebble Commercial Ice Maker Machine earns its place on the list due to its impressive features, surpassing many other undercounter ice makers.

With a substantial 100 lbs/day ice production capacity, a sizable 33 lbs ice storage basket, 2-way water adding capability, customizable 7-gear ice thickness control, and a convenient 24-hour timer, it offers unparalleled versatility for a wide range of applications, from bars and restaurants to offices and homes.

Additionally, the self-cleaning function streamlines maintenance, ensuring a consistently hygienic ice production process.

While it may come with a larger footprint and a potential investment, its rich feature set makes it a top choice for those seeking a robust and customizable undercounter ice maker.

(HIGHEST QUALITY)
Scotsman Gourmet Undercounter Ice Maker

Ice Shape: Gourmet ice

Production Speed: 65 Lbs/Day -24 Minutes per Batch

Ice Storage Capacity: 26 Pounds of ice

Dimensions: 34.38 x 14.88 x 22 inches

Energy Star certified

Pros:

1. High-Quality Gourmet Ice: The Scotsman CU50PA produces Air cooled gourmet ice cubes known for their hardness and impurity-free quality, enhancing the overall beverage experience.

2. Generous Ice Production: This Machine Produces up to 65 pounds of gourmet ice per day and store up to 26 pounds in its internal storage bin ensures a steady supply of fresh ice, making it suitable for various settings.

3. Versatile Use: This ice maker is versatile and can be used in homes, offices, company suites, and even outdoor locations like decks or patios due to its UL approval for indoor and outdoor use.

4. Energy-Efficient: The CU50PA is Energy Star qualified, which means it operates efficiently, saving energy and costs over time.

5. Compact Size: Measuring just 15 inches wide, it can fit into various locations, making it a convenient choice for limited space.

6. Alert Features: The ice maker provides alerts for ‘no water’ conditions and prompts users when it’s time for cleaning, ensuring proper operation and maintenance.

7. Built-In Drain Pump: The built-in drain pump simplifies the installation process, making it easier for users to set up the ice maker.

Cons:

1. Price: While it offers excellent features and quality, the Scotsman CU50PA may have a higher initial price than other undercounter ice makers.

2. LimitedIce Storage: While the ice production capacity is substantial, the internal storage bin can hold up to 26 pounds, which may require more frequent monitoring and emptying in high-demand situations.

The Scotsman CU50PA is a premium undercounter ice maker with features like gourmet ice production, versatile use, energy efficiency, and convenient alerts.

However, buyers should consider their specific needs and budget when purchasing.

(BEST PRODUCTION & STORAGE BIN)
TYLZA Commercial Ice Maker

Ice Shape: Cubes

Production Speed: 160 Lbs/Day -14 Minutes per Batch

Ice Storage Capacity: 35 Pounds of ice

Dimensions: 17 x 15 x 31.5 inches

Energy star certified

Pros:

1. High Ice Production Capacity: The TYLZA Commercial Ice Maker impressively produces 160 lbs of ice every 24 hours, making it suitable for high-demand environments such as restaurants and bars.

2. Large Ice Storage Capacity: With a 35 lbs ice storage capacity, it can store a significant amount of ice, reducing the need for frequent emptying and ensuring a steady ice supply.

3. Versatile Installation: This ice maker can be installed as a built-in or freestanding unit, providing flexibility in placement to accommodate different settings and preferences.

4. Stainless Steel Build: The stainless steel construction of this ice maker adds durability and offers a sleek and modern appearance that fits well in various settings.

5. Smart Panel: The smart panel simplifies operation and monitoring, enhancing user convenience and control.

6. Strong Compressor: A strong compressor ensures efficient and consistent ice production, reducing downtime and ensuring a continuous ice supply.

Cons:

1. Price: The TYLZA Commercial Ice Maker may come with a higher upfront cost than some undercounter ice makers, which could be a consideration for budget-conscious buyers.

2. Large Size: With this Ice maker, it’s ice production and storage capacity may result in a larger physical footprint, requiring ample space for installation.

3. Noise Level: High-capacity ice makers can generate noticeable noise during operation, which could be considered in quieter environments.

4. Maintenance Requirements: While it may have self-cleaning capabilities, users should still be prepared for routine maintenance tasks to ensure optimal performance and cleanliness.

Overall, the TYLZA Commercial Ice Maker offers a remarkable ice production capacity, storage, and convenient features like a smart panel.

It is well-suited for demanding environments but should be evaluated in the context of specific needs, budget, and available space.

The Final DEALiciousness Verdict:

After thoroughly evaluating five impressive undercounter ice maker reviews, the EUHOMY Commercial Under Counter Ice Maker Machine stands out as the clear top pick for several compelling reasons.

The EUHOMY ice maker combines a high ice production capacity of 100 lbs/day with user-friendly features, making it an excellent choice for various settings.

It offers customizable 7-gear ice thickness control, a 24-hour timer for energy-efficient operation, and a self-cleaning function to simplify maintenance.

Its stainless steel construction adds durability and a modern aesthetic.

While all five products have merits, the EUHOMY Commercial Ice Maker shines due to its exceptional performance and value.

It caters to high-demand environments and offers homes, offices, and more versatility. Its robust feature set and competitive price point make it the top choice for those seeking a well-rounded and reliable undercounter ice machine.

While the other products have their strengths, including high ice production capacities and innovative features, the EUHOMY’s overall package, balance of price, performance, and versatility, makes it the best choice for a wide range of users and applications.

In the Under Counter ice maker world, choosing the perfect match is like finding the ideal flavor of ice cream – it’s all about personal preference.

Each contender we’ve reviewed brings unique features and benefits, making the decision-making process akin to selecting your go-to scoop from an ice cream parlor.

While there’s no one-size-fits-all answer regarding under counter ice makers, I hope these reviews have played the role of a trusty flavor guide, helping you navigate the frosty terrain.

They’ve aimed to take some guesswork out of the equation, shedding light on each contender’s strengths and quirks so you can make an informed choice.

Whether you’re a gourmet ice aficionado, a space-saving wizard, or an energy-conscious hero, there’s an under counter ice maker with your name on it.

So, as you embark on your quest for the best undercounter ice maker, remember that your taste, needs, and priorities will ultimately determine the perfect fit. Here’s to staying cool and making every drink an icy delight!

Another Best of the Best Article You Might also Enjoy: Best Stand Mixers under $100